Jesse Appleton, D.D., Late President of Bowdoin College, Lectures, Delivered at Bowdoin College, and Occasional Sermons (Brunswick: printed by Joseph Griffin, 1822), Lecture XIII, "Atonement," p. 147

By what has been said, thus much at least, I conceive, has been made to appear, that there is not an obvious propriety in forgiving sin without atonement; and that, according to the best views, which we can entertain on…